Captain Sisay #250 from Magic Mystery Booster 2 is worth about $27.83 raw (Near Mint) as of Aug 24, 2026. Trade-in offers typically run $17–$24 raw.
| Condition | Market | Cash Offer Range |
|---|---|---|
| Near Mint | $27.83 | $17 – $24 |
| Lightly Played | $22.26 | $13 – $19 |
| Moderately Played | $16.70 | $10 – $14 |
| Heavily Played | $11.13 | $7 – $9 |
| Damaged | $6.96 | $4 – $6 |
Your card’s condition directly affects its trade-in value. Most cards from binders are Lightly Played or better. Estimates based on standard condition discounts.
Prices from PriceCharting & JustTCG · Updated Aug 24, 2026
| Route | Gross | Fees | Shipping | You Keep | Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sell to a Local Buyer | $17–$24 | $0 | $0 | $17–$24 | Same day |
| Sell on eBay | $27.83 | −$3.69 | −$5.00 | $19.14 | 2–4 wks |
| Sell on TCGplayer | $26.44 | −$2.88 | −$4.00 | $19.56 | 2–3 wks |
Local buyers found on Trade Into Cash typically pay 60–85% of market value with no fees. eBay: 13.25% final value fee. TCGplayer: 10.89% seller fee. Shipping estimated for standard tracked.
Enter your zip code to find local buyers who pay cash for trading cards.
The Captain Sisay #250 (Magic Mystery Booster 2) currently trades at $27.83 raw. Find a local buyer on Trade Into Cash for same-day cash.