Recurring Nightmare (Magic Exodus)
Recurring Nightmare from Magic Exodus is worth about $69.00 raw (Near Mint) as of Aug 24, 2026. Trade-in offers typically run $41–$59 raw.
Raw Trade-In Value by Condition
| Condition | Market | Cash Offer Range |
|---|---|---|
| Near Mint | $69.00 | $41 – $59 |
| Lightly Played | $55.20 | $33 – $47 |
| Moderately Played | $41.40 | $25 – $35 |
| Heavily Played | $27.60 | $17 – $23 |
| Damaged | $17.25 | $10 – $15 |
Your card’s condition directly affects its trade-in value. Most cards from binders are Lightly Played or better. Estimates based on standard condition discounts.
Graded Prices
| Grade | Price | Cash Offer Range |
|---|---|---|
| PSA 9.5 | $128 | $77 – $109 |
| PSA 9 | $108 | $65 – $92 |
| PSA 8 | $58 | $35 – $49 |
| PSA 7 | $50 | $30 – $42 |
| CGC 10 | $165 | $99 – $140 |
Prices from PriceCharting & JustTCG · Updated Aug 24, 2026
How to Sell: Compare Your Options
| Route | Gross | Fees | Shipping | You Keep | Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sell to a Local Buyer | $41–$59 | $0 | $0 | $41–$59 | Same day |
| Sell on eBay | $69.00 | −$9.14 | −$5.00 | $54.86 | 2–4 wks |
| Sell on TCGplayer | $65.55 | −$7.14 | −$4.00 | $54.41 | 2–3 wks |
Local buyers found on Trade Into Cash typically pay 60–85% of market value with no fees. eBay: 13.25% final value fee. TCGplayer: 10.89% seller fee. Shipping estimated for standard tracked.
Sell This Card Locally
Enter your zip code to find local buyers who pay cash for trading cards.
About Recurring Nightmare
The Recurring Nightmare from Magic Exodus is a Magic: The Gathering trading card. Raw copies in Near Mint condition currently trade around $69.00. Local buyers on Trade Into Cash offer same-day cash at 60–85% of market value.