Home›Indianapolis›Sports Cards
Indianapolis, IN · Sports Cards

Sports Card Shops in Indianapolis That Buy Cards

27 local buyers across Indianapolis — including Elf 'N Moon Gaming & Hobby, Anything Gaming & Repair and Game World — pay cash for used sports cards. Average buyer rating 4.4★ across 6,710 Google reviews. Pick your device below to compare local offers.

Free quotes, no obligation · Same-day meetups · Every condition assessed in hand

Serving Indianapolis, Greenwood, Avon, Carmel, Noblesville, Amo, Bargersville and more

Choose Your Game

What are you selling?

27 local buyers in Indianapolis · 5 sports · tap one to see who buys it.

Baseball Cards

Sell Baseball Cards

Topps, Bowman, Panini, vintage

Football Cards

Sell Football Cards

Panini, Topps, Select, Prizm

Basketball Cards

Sell Basketball Cards

Panini, NBA Hoops, Donruss

Hockey Cards

Sell Hockey Cards

Upper Deck, O-Pee-Chee, SP

Soccer Cards

Sell Soccer Cards

Topps, Panini, Match Attax

Local Buyers — 27 buyers in Indianapolis

SORT:
S
Southside Sports Cards
Free quote · No obligation
★ 2.3 (3)
Mon Closed · Tue–Sun 10am–6pm
3825 S East St, Indianapolis, IN 46227
4 mi away
Call Now
View Profile → Get directions
G
Grandmaster Games
Free quote · No obligation
★ 4.3 (594)
Mon 12pm–7pm · Tue–Wed 12pm–9:30pm · Thu 12pm–7pm · Fri 12pm–9:30pm · Sat–Sun 11am–7pm
4200 S East St Ste 20, Indianapolis, IN 46227
5 mi away
Call Now
View Profile → Get directions
T
The Dugout
Free quote · No obligation
★ 4.2 (295)
Mon 11am–8:30pm · Tue–Thu 11am–9pm · Fri 11am–11pm · Sat 11am–6pm · Sun Closed
5707 W Morris St, Indianapolis, IN 46241
6 mi away
Call Now
View Profile → Get directions
GameStop
GameStop
Free quote · No obligation
Only buys cards graded by PSA
★ 4.0 (340)
Mon–Thu 10am–9pm · Fri–Sat 9am–10pm · Sun 10am–7pm
10415 E US Hwy 36, Avon, IN 46123, USA
10 mi away
Cash
Call Now
View Profile → Get directions
T
The Toy Drop
Free quote · No obligation
★ 4.7 (255)
Mon–Sat 11am–6pm · Sun 12pm–5pm
6025 Madison Ave E, Indianapolis, IN 46227
7 mi away
Call Now
View Profile → Get directions
O
Oldschool Outpost
Free quote · No obligation
★ 4.7 (81)
Mon 12pm–9pm · Tue–Fri 11am–9pm · Sat 10am–9pm · Sun 12pm–8pm
5215 E Thompson Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46237
7 mi away
Call Now
View Profile → Get directions

Listings come from public Google Business profiles; we don’t vet or endorse them, and ratings are Google’s. How our listings and prices work

Where they are

Where Indianapolis’s 27 card buyers are

Grouped by the town on each buyer’s Google address; distance is from the center of Indianapolis.

Indianapolis, within 5 mi of the center 7
  • Good Games Indianapolis 1.0 mi · 4.6★ (485)
  • Paradigm Games 1.9 mi · 4.7★ (137)
  • Elf 'N Moon Gaming & Hobby 2.0 mi · 4.9★ (289)
  • Collectors Paradise 4.0 mi · 4.5★ (71)
  • Southside Sports Cards 4.5 mi · 2.3★ (3)
  • Anything Gaming & Repair 4.6 mi · 4.9★ (266)
  • The Card Depot 4.8 mi · 4.4★ (32)
Indianapolis, 5 mi or more from the center 15
  • Grandmaster Games 5.1 mi · 4.3★ (594)
  • Fan Cave 5.6 mi · 4.4★ (124)
  • The Dugout 6.2 mi · 4.2★ (295)
  • Indy Card Shop 6.4 mi · 4.5★ (33)
  • Oldschool Outpost 6.7 mi · 4.7★ (81)
  • Indy RC Raceway & Hobbies/ Hobby RC 6.8 mi · 4.6★ (351)
  • The "Haven" 6.8 mi · 5★ (4)
  • The Toy Drop 6.8 mi · 4.7★ (255)
  • and 7 more
Greenwood 2
  • GameStop (Greenwood) 10.2 mi · 3.9★ (221)
  • K & L Cards 10.9 mi · 4.2★ (174)
Avon 1
  • GameStop (Avon) 10.3 mi · 4★ (340)
Carmel 1
  • Next Level Games Carmel 16.4 mi · 4.8★ (176)
Noblesville 1
  • GameStop (Noblesville) 18.7 mi · 3.8★ (208)
When to go

Weekend and evening hours

From the posted Google hours of the 23 buyers with a full week listed. Call before a long drive; hours change.

18open Sunday
  • Good Games Indianapolis11am–9pm
  • Elf 'N Moon Gaming & Hobby11am–10pm
  • Collectors Paradise12:30pm–5pm
  • Southside Sports Cards10am–6pm
  • Grandmaster Games11am–7pm
Show 13 more
  • Oldschool Outpost12pm–8pm
  • Indy RC Raceway & Hobbies/ Hobby RC10am–8pm
  • The Toy Drop12pm–5pm
  • GameStop (U.S. 31 N)10am–7pm
  • Game World12pm–7pm
  • GameStop (E Washington St B)10am–7pm
  • Game Preserve11am–6pm
  • GameStop (E 82nd St)11am–6pm
  • GameStop (Greenwood)11am–8pm
  • GameStop (Avon)10am–7pm
  • K & L Cards12pm–6pm
  • Indy Card Exchange12pm–5pm
  • Next Level Games Carmel12pm–10pm
18open until 8pm or later
  • Elf 'N Moon Gaming & Hobbyuntil midnight
  • Next Level Games Carmeluntil midnight
  • The Dugoutuntil 11pm
  • Good Games Indianapolisuntil 10pm
  • GameStop (U.S. 31 N)until 10pm
Show 13 more
  • GameStop (E Washington St B)until 10pm
  • Game Timeuntil 10pm
  • GameStop (Avon)until 10pm
  • Grandmaster Gamesuntil 9:30pm
  • Oldschool Outpostuntil 9pm
  • Game Worlduntil 9pm
  • Game Preserveuntil 9pm
  • GameStop (E 82nd St)until 9pm
  • GameStop (Greenwood)until 9pm
  • GameStop (Noblesville)until 9pm
  • Fan Caveuntil 8pm
  • Indy RC Raceway & Hobbies/ Hobby RCuntil 8pm
  • K & L Cardsuntil 8pm
3open by 9am
  • GameStop (U.S. 31 N)from 9am
  • GameStop (E Washington St B)from 9am
  • GameStop (Avon)from 9am
Who’s buying

Independent shops, chains and what else they’re listed for

21 independent6 GameStop

The most-reviewed independent shops are Game Preserve (709 reviews, 4.7★), Grandmaster Games (594 reviews, 4.3★) and Good Games Indianapolis (485 reviews, 4.6★). 1 of the 27 are listed only for sports cards. Of the other 26, all 26 are also listed for trading card games; 6 are also listed for phones, smartwatches, computers, game consoles and tablets.

Compared with the Pokémon card shops in Indianapolis: Southside Sports Cards is listed for sports cards but not for trading card games; Mage's Comics and Games is listed for trading card games but not sports cards.

By type

Sports cards: who takes what

Which of the 27 Indianapolis buyers list each type.

Baseball Cards

None of the 27 Indianapolis buyers is listed for Baseball Cards yet; ask before you drive.

Football Cards

None of the 27 Indianapolis buyers is listed for Football Cards yet; ask before you drive.

Basketball Cards

None of the 27 Indianapolis buyers is listed for Basketball Cards yet; ask before you drive.

Hockey Cards

None of the 27 Indianapolis buyers is listed for Hockey Cards yet; ask before you drive.

Soccer Cards

None of the 27 Indianapolis buyers is listed for Soccer Cards yet; ask before you drive.

Before you go

Graded or rawPSA, BGS and SGC slabs are priced off recent sales. Raw cards are graded by eye.
Sort firstPull rookies, numbered parallels, autographs and vintage stars out of the commons.
ConditionCorners, edges, centering and surface decide what a raw card is worth.
Bulk1987–1994 base cards were overprinted and sell as bulk at best.
GameStopGameStop buys PSA-graded cards only.

Indianapolis card buyers: questions

Which card shops in Indianapolis buy sports cards?

Indianapolis, within 5 mi of the center: Good Games Indianapolis (1.0 mi), Paradigm Games (1.9 mi), Elf 'N Moon Gaming & Hobby (2.0 mi) and 4 more; Indianapolis, 5 mi or more from the center: Grandmaster Games (5.1 mi), Fan Cave (5.6 mi), The Dugout (6.2 mi) and 12 more; Greenwood: GameStop (Greenwood) (10.2 mi) and K & L Cards (10.9 mi); Avon: GameStop (Avon) (10.3 mi). The full list, with hours and directions, is above.

Which Indianapolis card shops are open on Sunday?

18 of the 23 with a full week of posted hours: Good Games Indianapolis (11am–9pm), Elf 'N Moon Gaming & Hobby (11am–10pm), Collectors Paradise (12:30pm–5pm), Southside Sports Cards (10am–6pm), Grandmaster Games (11am–7pm), Oldschool Outpost (12pm–8pm) and 12 more.

Which sports cards are worth selling?

Rookie cards of current stars, numbered parallels, autographs, vintage Hall of Famers and graded slabs are what shops pay for.

Nearby areas

Selling sports cards near Indianapolis?

Sell sports cards in AvonSell sports cards in NoblesvilleSell sports cards in FranklinSell sports cards in MartinsvilleSell sports cards in AndersonSell sports cards in MuncieSell sports cards in BloomingtonSell sports cards in Lafayette
Also Buying

Not selling sports cards?

Local buyers in Indianapolis are also listed for these categories.

CamerasCell PhonesSmartwatchesComputersGame ConsolesTabletsJewelry & WatchesClothing & HandbagsMusical InstrumentsCollectible Card GamesLEGO

Sports Cards: see buyers in every city →