Middletown, NY · Sports Cards

Sports Card Shops in Middletown That Buy Cards

2 local buyers across Middletown pay cash for used sports cards. Average buyer rating 4.0★ across 422 Google reviews. Pick your device below to compare local offers.

Free quotes, no obligation · Same-day meetups · Every condition assessed in hand

Serving Middletown, Fredon Township, Bloomingburg, Bullville, Burlingham, Circleville, Cragsmoor and more

Choose Your Game

What are you selling?

2 local buyers in Middletown · 5 sports · tap one to see who buys it.

Sell Baseball Cards

Topps, Bowman, Panini, vintage

Sell Football Cards

Panini, Topps, Select, Prizm

Sell Basketball Cards

Panini, NBA Hoops, Donruss

Sell Hockey Cards

Upper Deck, O-Pee-Chee, SP

Sell Soccer Cards

Topps, Panini, Match Attax

Local Buyers — 2 buyers in Middletown

SORT:

GameStop

Free quote · No obligation

Only buys cards graded by PSA

★ 3.9 (243)

Mon–Thu 12pm–8pm · Fri–Sat 11am–9pm · Sun 12pm–8pm

400 NY-211 Ste 23, Middletown, NY 10940, USA

Cash

Call Now

View Profile → Get directions

GameStop

Free quote · No obligation

Only buys cards graded by PSA

★ 4.1 (179)

Mon–Thu 10am–9pm · Fri–Sat 9am–10pm · Sun 10am–7pm

9 Hampton House Rd #17, Fredon Township, NJ 07860, USA

31 mi away

Cash

Call Now

View Profile → Get directions

Listings come from public Google Business profiles; we don’t vet or endorse them, and ratings are Google’s. How our listings and prices work

Where they are

Where Middletown’s 2 card buyers are

Grouped by the town on each buyer’s Google address; distance is from the center of Middletown.

Middletown, within 5 mi of the center 1

GameStop (NY-211) 1.9 mi · 3.9★ (243)

Fredon Township 1

GameStop (Fredon Township) 30.8 mi · 4.1★ (179)

When to go

Weekend and evening hours

From the posted Google hours of the 2 buyers with a full week listed. Call before a long drive; hours change.

2open Sunday

GameStop (NY-211)12pm–8pm
GameStop (Fredon Township)10am–7pm

2open until 8pm or later

GameStop (Fredon Township)until 10pm
GameStop (NY-211)until 9pm

1open by 9am

GameStop (Fredon Township)from 9am

Who’s buying

Independent shops, chains and what else they’re listed for

2 GameStop

Every buyer listed here is a chain location. 2 are also listed for phones, smartwatches, computers, game consoles, tablets and trading card games.

By type

Sports cards: who takes what

Which of the 2 Middletown buyers list each type.

Baseball Cards

None of the 2 Middletown buyers is listed for Baseball Cards yet; ask before you drive.

Football Cards

None of the 2 Middletown buyers is listed for Football Cards yet; ask before you drive.

Basketball Cards

None of the 2 Middletown buyers is listed for Basketball Cards yet; ask before you drive.

Hockey Cards

None of the 2 Middletown buyers is listed for Hockey Cards yet; ask before you drive.

Soccer Cards

None of the 2 Middletown buyers is listed for Soccer Cards yet; ask before you drive.

Before you go

Graded or rawPSA, BGS and SGC slabs are priced off recent sales. Raw cards are graded by eye.

Sort firstPull rookies, numbered parallels, autographs and vintage stars out of the commons.

ConditionCorners, edges, centering and surface decide what a raw card is worth.

Bulk1987–1994 base cards were overprinted and sell as bulk at best.

GameStopGameStop buys PSA-graded cards only.

Middletown card buyers: questions

Which card shops in Middletown buy sports cards?

Middletown, within 5 mi of the center: GameStop (NY-211) (1.9 mi); Fredon Township: GameStop (Fredon Township) (30.8 mi).

Which Middletown card shops are open on Sunday?

2 of the 2 with a full week of posted hours: GameStop (NY-211) (12pm–8pm) and GameStop (Fredon Township) (10am–7pm).

Which sports cards are worth selling?

Rookie cards of current stars, numbered parallels, autographs, vintage Hall of Famers and graded slabs are what shops pay for.

Nearby areas

Selling sports cards near Middletown?

Sell sports cards in Spring Valley Sell sports cards in Ossining Sell sports cards in Randolph Sell sports cards in Paterson Sell sports cards in Stroudsburg Sell sports cards in Yonkers Sell sports cards in Danbury Sell sports cards in Newark

Also Buying

Not selling sports cards?

Local buyers in Middletown are also listed for these categories.

Cell Phones Smartwatches Computers Game Consoles Tablets Collectible Card Games

Sports Cards: see buyers in every city →