Newburgh, IN · Game Consoles

Sell Your PlayStation, Xbox or Nintendo for Cash in Newburgh

5 local buyers across Newburgh — including CLEVER BAY SPORTS & GAMING, GameStop and Mega Replay — pay cash for used game consoles. Average buyer rating 4.3★ across 3,268 Google reviews. Pick your device below to compare local offers.

Free quotes, no obligation · Same-day meetups · Broken consoles accepted

Serving Newburgh, Evansville, Owensboro, Boonville, Reed, Richland

Choose Your Device

What are you selling?

5 local buyers in Newburgh · 4 device families · tap a device to see who buys it.

Sell PlayStation

PS5, PS4, all models and bundles

5 buyers →

See PlayStation prices →

Sell Xbox

Xbox Series X, Series S, One and more

5 buyers →

See Xbox prices →

Sell Nintendo

Switch, Switch OLED, Switch Lite

5 buyers →

See Nintendo prices →

Sell Steam Deck

All Steam Deck models

5 buyers →

Local Buyers — Nearest buyers to Newburgh — closest is 5 mi

SORT:

Mega Replay

Free quote · No obligation

★ 4.3 (1,890)

Mon–Sat 10am–9pm · Sun 11am–7pm

683 N Green River Rd, Evansville, IN 47715

6 mi away

Call Now Get directions View Profile →

The Book Broker

Free quote · No obligation

★ 4.3 (696)

Mon–Sat 10am–8pm · Sun 12pm–6pm

2717 Covert Ave, Evansville, IN 47714

7 mi away

Call Now Get directions View Profile →

GameStop

Free quote · No obligation

★ 4.4 (205)

Mon–Thu 11am–7pm · Fri–Sat 11am–9pm · Sun Closed

3245 Mt Moriah Ave #2, Owensboro, KY 42303, USA

23 mi away

Cash

Call Now Get directions View Profile →

GameStop

Free quote · No obligation

★ 4.1 (345)

Mon–Thu 10 :00 AM–8 :00 PM · Fri–Sat 10 :00 AM–9 :00 PM · Sun Closed

800 N Green River Rd #57, Evansville, IN 47715, USA

6 mi away

Cash

Call Now Get directions View Profile →

CLEVER BAY SPORTS & GAMING

Free quote · No obligation

★ 4.7 (132)

Mon 12pm–6pm · Tue 12pm–8pm · Wed–Sat 10am–8pm · Sun 12pm–6pm

900 Tutor Ln #104, Evansville, IN 47715

5 mi away

Call Now Get directions View Profile →

Prices by device

Sell Your PlayStation in Newburgh

All 5 Newburgh buyers listed take PlayStation. Show the 5 PlayStation buyers →

PlayStation values in Newburgh — top models

What is your PlayStation worth?

Updated September 2026 · 18 models

Prices are estimated trade-in values and are not guaranteed. Use as a reference when negotiating with your local buyer in Newburgh. Pricing assumes the device is fully paid off, has not been reported lost or stolen, and is signed out of iCloud / Find My or your Google account.

PlayStation Playstation 5 Slim PS5 Console

$207 – $390

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation Playstation 5 Slim Digital Edition PS5 Console

$188 – $355

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation 5 Digital Edition

$183 – $345

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation 5 Disk Edition

$131 – $247

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation Playstation 4 Pro Black PS4 Console

$73 – $138

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation Playstation 4 PS4 Black Console

$72 – $135

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation Playstation 4 PS4 White Console

$72 – $135

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation Playstation 4 Pro White PS4 Pro Console

$60 – $114

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation Playstation 4 Slim White PS4 Console

$53 – $100

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation 2 Slim

$50 – $95

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation 2

$50 – $95

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation Playstation 4 Slim Black PS4 Console

$40 – $76

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation Portable Vita WiFi 3G

$34 – $65

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation Portable Vita WiFi Only

$32 – $60

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation Portable Go

$19 – $35

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation Portable PSP 3000 PSP-3000 Handheld System

$11 – $20

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation Portable Street E1004

$11 – $20

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

PlayStation Portable Slim Lite PSP-2000 Handheld System

$10 – $18

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Sell Your Xbox in Newburgh

All 5 Newburgh buyers listed take Xbox. Show the 5 Xbox buyers →

Xbox values in Newburgh — top models

What is your Xbox worth?

Updated September 2026 · 5 models

Microsoft Xbox Series X Disc Drive Edition

$286 – $540

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Microsoft Xbox Series S All-Digital Edition

$188 – $355

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Microsoft Xbox Xbox One S Console

$53 – $100

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Microsoft Xbox One X

$48 – $90

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Microsoft Xbox Xbox One

$40 – $76

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Sell Your Nintendo in Newburgh

All 5 Newburgh buyers listed take Nintendo. Show the 5 Nintendo buyers →

Nintendo values in Newburgh — top models

What is your Nintendo worth?

Updated September 2026 · 36 models

Nintendo Switch Console Switch 2

$170 – $320

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

3DS New 3DS XL

$127 – $240

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Switch Console Switch OLED White

$93 – $175

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Switch Console Switch

$64 – $120

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Wii U Console Wii U Deluxe

$40 – $75

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Switch Console Switch Lite

$40 – $75

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

2DS New 2DS XL Handheld Console

$36 – $67

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Wii U Console Wii U Basic

$34 – $65

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo 64 Console 64 N64 Console

$26 – $50

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo SNES Console Classic Edition 2017

$23 – $44

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

2DS 2DS

$15 – $29

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

DS DSI XL

$14 – $27

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Gameboy Gameboy Advance SP AGS-101

$13 – $25

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo NES Console NES Classic Edition 2016

$13 – $25

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Gameboy Virtual Boy VUE-001

$13 – $25

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo NES Console NES-101 Control Deck Top Loader

$13 – $25

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo SNES Console Super Nintendo SNES Mini SNS-101 Console

$11 – $20

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo SNES Console Super Nintendo SNES SNS-001 Original Console

$11 – $20

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

DS DSI

$9 – $17

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Gameboy Gameboy Light Gold Japan

$8 – $15

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Gameboy Gameboy Micro Gold Red 20th Anniversary

$8 – $15

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Gameboy Gameboy Light Silver Japan

$8 – $15

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Wii Console Wii White

$8 – $15

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Gameboy Gameboy Micro Silver OXY-001

$8 – $15

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Wii Console Wii Blue

$8 – $15

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Wii Console Wii Red

$8 – $15

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Wii Console Wii Black

$8 – $15

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Gameboy Gameboy Advance AGB-001

$6 – $12

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

DS DS Lite

$6 – $11

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

DS DS Original

$5 – $10

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Gameboy Gameboy Color CGB-001

$5 – $10

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Gameboy Gameboy Original DMG-01

$5 – $10

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo NES Console Messiah Generation NEX Console

$5 – $10

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo GameCube Console GameCube Original Console

$5 – $10

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo NES Console NES NES-001 Console

$5 – $10

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Nintendo Gameboy Gameboy Pocket MGB-001

$4 – $8

⌄

Select Condition

Pick the tier that honestly matches your console.

Sell Your Steam Deck in Newburgh

All 5 Newburgh buyers listed take Steam Deck. Show the 5 Steam Deck buyers →

Maximize Your Trade-In Value

🎮

Include all controllers and cables
A complete console with original controllers, power cable, and HDMI sells for significantly more than the console alone.

✨

Clean the console thoroughly
Wipe down the console, clean dust from vents, and remove any stickers. A clean unit looks well-maintained.

📦

Include the original box
Consoles with original packaging and manuals can sell for 15–25% more than loose units.

🔄

Factory reset before selling
Delete your account, saved data, and sign out of any online services. Buyers want a fresh start.

Why Sell Locally in Newburgh?

Same-day cash — 5 of the 5 Newburgh buyers with posted hours are open today; walk in, get quoted, get paid.
Real competition — 5 Newburgh buyers quote against each other; the top-rated, CLEVER BAY SPORTS & GAMING, holds 4.7★ across 132 Google reviews.
Close by — CLEVER BAY SPORTS & GAMING is 4.7 mi from central Newburgh, and 4 of 5 mapped buyers sit within 10 miles.

Frequently Asked Questions — Game Consoles in Newburgh

Where can I sell my console for cash in Newburgh?

The 5 local buyers listed above pay cash for game consoles in Newburgh; CLEVER BAY SPORTS & GAMING is the highest-rated (4.7★ over 132 Google reviews) and also the closest to central Newburgh (4.7 mi).

How much can I get for my console?

It depends on make, model, and condition. Text CLEVER BAY SPORTS & GAMING or any of the other 4 buyers above with the details for a quote.

Do you buy cracked or broken game consoles in Newburgh?

Yes — 5 Newburgh buyers assess disc drive issues, controller drift, or cosmetic damage in hand. The nearest listed buyer, CLEVER BAY SPORTS & GAMING, is 4.7 mi from central Newburgh.

Nearby areas

Selling game consoles near Newburgh?

Sell game consoles in Owensboro Sell game consoles in Evansville Sell game consoles in Hopkinsville

Zip codes served: 47630, 42451, 47601, 47634

Also Buying

Not selling game consoles?

We buy all major electronics categories in Newburgh.

Cameras Cell Phones Smartwatches Computers Tablets Jewelry & Watches Clothing & Handbags Musical Instruments Sports Cards Collectible Card Games LEGO